... '
-
,
:
. .,
. .,
""
.
""' .
, ""
"" , ,
.
,
"" ""
. -
""
,
.
ߺ
- -
㳿 ,
"" ""
"" .
, -,
, ,
- , ,
, ,
,
.
ISBN 966-7288-34-X
. . , 1998
,
- , "" ,
( ) .
,
, ""
, ,
.
,
"-", ,
" ", .
, ߺ
"", , ,
"" , ""
.
,
' ߺ
"" ,
' .
"--"
"" "" . ,
䳿, , -
- (
),
, ,
"", ,
, ""
"" " " -
"". , , 䳿
""
"" .
- .
"""
,
, - .
.
, ,
"" ,
, ,
"", .
- .
, ,
' "" ,
, ,
,
. ""
-
, , ,
.
' , ,
, '
,
, .
. ߺ
"" ?
" " ? ?
"" ,
? , ,
""
()?
""
- ?
"" ?
" "
,
?
'
,
, -
( )
.
- -
, ,
,
"" -
,
.
"" ,
-- , ,
.
"""
,
, ,
,
, '
, , .
,
, ,
㳿,
"" .
,
"" .
, ,
, (
) ,
,
,
.
, ,
, ' ,
- ,
'
""
- """ .
,
"""
,
.
, ( )
"'" .
1. "" '
/. /. "" '
""
- .
,
,
, ,
-, , ""
. , ,
, 䳿
" ", "" --
- -.
""" '
, . ,
"" ߺ ' ,
, "".
, """ ,
,
- . '
,
' ' ""
.
"" -
.
""
,
(- - , ,
- ).
, - """
,
.
,
""" .
: " ", " ", "
() ", " ", " ", "
", " ", " ", "
", "", " ", " ",
" " .
,
"" ,
, , ,
.
- , ""
ߺ - ,
( ),
.
"" , ""
,
- .
,
, . ,
,
( ,
), ' ,
(,
)
.
'
"" . ""
,
- .
, ',
"" , .
, ""
. -
"""
, '.
,
""
.
, " "
"",
, .
1 , ,
""
. , 70- - 80-
"" . 1984
. ,
"" . ,
, 볿,
.
.
.: . ., . . :
( -). - .: . - 1987. -
. 43.
'
.
"" "", "-"
,
, -
.
,
,
, :
( "", "") "" ().
(""), ""
. ""
, '
.
, ,
"" , ,
. "" ' ""
"", "",
""" ""
, , (. . 1, 2, 3 4).
""
,
, /
/ (. . 1, 4).
""
' , , . () ""
,
. (.: . ., . . : -
( ). - .: .-
1987.-.4.
. 1
1. "" ("", "", "") . 1.
"" ( -
).
3. "" ( "'" :
, ), "-"
.
4. .
4.1. "-" (
.
4.2. "" ( , "-")
.
4.3. "" .
""
2 (), 3 4. ""
4
(4.1, 4.2 4.3).
10
11
(
), ߺ ,
. ,
, , ,
' .
. , ,
.
, ,
, , ,
,
'.
,
,
,
, .
("-" )
(, , ,
), -.
, ,
,
, .
, ,
' - , '
. ,
, ,
, .
12
'
, ,
' ,
(
) .
,
"" . ,
, , 糿, ,
. ,
, '
, '
,
.
"-" "" '
(,
;
; ;
). .
.
: " "
"" ("underground" "subterranean") .
,
. ""
,
, .
.
,
, .
, /
.
13
"" ( . . ) "" ,
. ,
,
, :
, , , , ""
, " ", .
,
.
, .
(, ߺ,
).
""" ()
, , ,
.
, ""
"" () ,
. "
" ,
. " " ߺ
' --
, .
,
, .
"" ,
, ( ,
"", ,
: -- , -- ).
, , ,
,
,
14
,
( ), '
, '
.
1.2. ""
-
"" , ,
- ,
. , ,
"", .
,
, "" ,
"" ,
.
'
, . ""
60- --
70- , 80- --
-
. , ""
,
,
.
"""
, ,
'.
.: Grossman G. Notes on the Legal Private Economy and Corruption //
Soviet Economy in a Time of Change: A Compendium of Papers Submitted to the
Joint
15
, , 䳿
-- "" . ,
. . , No 1
" " 1971 p. " "".
,
"" () " .
. , , ,
, "", "
", " ", " ", "
" .
1984 .
"" ,
"" 2. ,
,
-- "" 3.
- 80-
""
, "" .
, .
, , . ,
, , ,
Economic Committee Congress of the United States, vol. 2. 1979 October
10. Washington: VS Gov.Printing Off. 1979; - P. 844; Rummer W. Structural
Imbalance in the Soviet Economy// Problems of Communism. 1984. July-August,
vol. 33 No 4. -P. 26; Feldbrugge F. J. M. Goverment and Shadow Economy in
the Soviet Union// Soviet Studies, vol. 36. - October 1984. - No 4. - P.
528 - 543.
' . .:
- // . . . . - M.: . - 1981.
- . 267 - 272.
.: Feldbrygge F. G. M. Goverment and Shadow Economy in the Soviet
Union// Soviet Studies. Vol. 36. - October 1984. - No 4. - P. 528.
Ibid. - P. 528 - 543.
"- ", " ",
-- "" (),
,
, .
""" (""") :
, , ""
.
. , . , .
'.
""" (""")
() "" ,
, ,
. ,
. : " "" ,
, , ,
(.
1977, 1979). , ,
, , ,
""" "2.
""
, .
. 179
""" , 9 .
, , ,
" ", 3.
' .: Grossman G. The "Second Economy" of the USSR/ Problems of
Communism, 1977. Vol. 26. No 5. - P. 25 - 40; Rumer . The "Second"
Agriculture in the USSR// Soviet studies. Vol. 26. - No 4. - P. 560 - 572;
Roncek L. Private Enterprise in Soviet Political Debate// Soviet studies.
Vol. 40, Jan. 1988. - No 1. - P. 46 - 63.
2 .: Bergson A. Income Ineguality Under Soviet Socialism// The
Journal of Economic Literature. September. - 1984. - Vol. 22 . - P. 1057.
.: Feldbrygge F. G. M. Goverment and Shadow Economy in the Soviet
Union// Soviet Studies. Vol. 36. - October 1984^ " " "
16
; , ( -J V
U
., 㓏 " p,e-nWs-'*i ᳂.' . 5. .
K"fussss!sa
^-^405^
"" ,
. ,
, .
(
, ).
"""
. . , ""
" "'.
. ,
2.
""
70- -
.
.
""
.
,
""" ,
- 3.
' : Grossman G. Notes on the Legal Private Economy and Corruption//
Op. cit. - P. 834 - 855.
2 : Grossman G. Notes on the Legal Private Economy and Corruption//
Op. cit. - P. 843.
3 ,
"'" '
(
"" ,
,
-
18
'
,
70- ,
.
""
.
"" , ,
"" ,
;
, ,
; ;
( ).
: , ,
;
(""),
; ("");
() ;
;
();
,
. """
"" (, , ,
). ""
.
, , ,
"" -- , ,
). .: . " "
(, , )// . - 1990. - No 3. - . 110 -
111.
19
, , ,
.'
"""
"". ,
' ,
"", ""
.
"", , ""
,
2. 80-
,